I Analyzed 53 Advisor Websites in One City. Here’s What I Found.
A few months ago I did something I’d been thinking about for a while. I pulled up every financial advisor website I could find in one mid-sized city, 53 in total, and applied a single test to each one.
I covered the logo. Then I asked: would a visitor still know who this website is built for?
Not what the firm does. Not what services they offer. Not what their philosophy is. Just, who is this for?
The results were striking. And they explain a lot about why most advisor marketing underperforms.
What I Found
Out of 53 websites, only 13 clearly signaled a specific audience. The other 40 did not.
Most of the non-specific sites led with some version of the same headline:
- “Helping individuals and families pursue financial confidence”
- “Comprehensive financial planning for every stage of life”
- “Tailored strategies for your financial future”
Professional. Polished. Interchangeable.
These sites communicate that a firm is competent. They don’t communicate who the firm is built for. And that distinction, competent versus built for someone specifically, is the entire difference between a website that converts and one that doesn’t.
The “Individuals and Families” Problem
One phrase appeared on 40 of the 53 sites in some form: “individuals and families.”
At first glance, it sounds reasonable. Until you realize it describes almost everyone.
When a phrase describes everyone, it resonates with no one. It becomes background noise, the marketing equivalent of a default answer.
Now compare that to a homepage that opens with something like:
“Helping Wichita dentists transition their practices without triggering avoidable taxes.”
One of those messages creates immediate curiosity for the right reader. The other disappears into a category.
What Broad Messaging Actually Signals
The 40 sites that didn’t define a specific audience weren’t just missing an opportunity. They were actively signaling something most advisors don’t intend.
When a homepage leads with services, credentials, and general promises, without defining who it’s for, it signals competence. And competence is assumed. Prospects don’t hire you because you’re competent. They hire you because they believe you’re specifically right for them.
Competence is the floor, not the differentiator. Positioning is the differentiator. And 40 out of 53 firms in this market were competing on the floor.
The Real Visibility Problem
Advisors who feel invisible in their market often believe they need more traffic. More reach. More promotion.
What this study shows is that most of those firms would benefit far more from clearer positioning than more visitors. If the message on your homepage could belong to ten different firms, more visitors don’t solve the problem. They simply expose it to a larger audience.
Before investing in more traffic, it’s worth asking a different question: when someone lands on your site, do they immediately understand who the firm is built to serve?
Or do they have to figure it out?
Cover your logo. Look at your homepage. Who is it for?
If the answer isn’t immediate, that’s the work.
Want this talk for your firm or association? Book Mike to Speak to Your Firm or Association →