Why Adding More Marketing Tactics Isn’t Growing Your Firm (And What to Fix First)
I once reviewed an 18-month marketing plan for a firm. It had 27 distinct tactics. More posts, more emails, more webinars, more tools, more outreach.
When I asked them who the plan was for, what specific audience all of this activity was aimed at, they couldn’t tell me.
That’s when I understood the real problem. And it had nothing to do with their tactics.
Strategy Is the Spine. Tactics Are the Limbs.
Limbs move. Spines decide.
When advisors and professional firms hit a growth plateau, the instinct is almost always to do more: more content, more platforms, more offers, more outreach. The assumption is that volume will eventually produce results.
But if the underlying strategy is weak, if the niche is vague, the message is generic, and there’s no clear point of view, adding more tactics doesn’t solve the problem. It amplifies it. You end up producing more content that doesn’t resonate, reaching more of the wrong people, and burning more time with less to show for it.
Tactics are not the problem. A missing spine is.
What a Weak Marketing Spine Looks Like
Most firms know they have a marketing problem. Fewer can identify why. Here are the signs that the spine is the issue, not the tactics:
- You’ve changed your primary marketing channel more than once in the last 18 months
- Different team members would give different answers about who your ideal client is
- Your content covers a wide range of topics but doesn’t build on a consistent central idea
- You generate activity (posts, emails, events) but can’t trace new clients back to a specific effort
- Your messaging sounds like your competitors’ messaging
If several of these are true, you don’t need more tactics. You need a stronger spine.
The Three Things a Strong Marketing Spine Does
A clear marketing strategy, what I’d call a strong spine, does three specific things:
First, it chooses the audience. Not “business owners” or “high-net-worth individuals” a real, specific audience whose problems you understand better than any competitor does. Choosing an audience isn’t limiting. It’s concentrating your energy where it produces the most signal.
Second, it defines the problem. Not the services you provide, but the specific challenge your ideal client is trying to solve. When your marketing names the problem your client is already experiencing, precisely and specifically, it creates recognition. They lean in instead of scrolling past.
Third, it claims a point of view. Generic firms produce generic content. Firms with a defined perspective on how their work should be done, and why, produce content that gets remembered, quoted, and shared. Your point of view is your differentiation, expressed.
Everything Else Is Extension
Once the spine is clear, tactics become much simpler. Content choices become obvious. The platform question answers itself. The message stays consistent without constant reinvention.
Without the spine, every tactical decision is a coin flip. Should we post more on LinkedIn or invest in webinars? Should we refresh the website? Should we try a newsletter? Without a strategic foundation, none of these questions has a reliable answer.
With a clear spine, most of them answer themselves.
If your growth feels random and your marketing feels exhausting, the problem probably isn’t the tactics you’re using. It’s that you haven’t yet built the foundation that makes tactics work.
Add all the tactics you want. Without a spine, they’ll collapse under their own weight.
Want this talk for your firm or association? Book Mike to Speak to Your Firm or Association →